CRICO Strategies homeCRICO Strategy home

Comparative Benchmarking System (CBS) Reports

In-depth evaluation of current trends in clinical risk.

Annual Comparative Benchmarking Reports

Diagnostic Process  | Routine Medical Procedures
Emergency Medicine | Obstetrics  | Surgery

CRICO Strategies’ Comparative Benchmarking System (CBS) is a robust repository of approximately 30 percent of U.S. malpractice cases. This HIPAA-compliant database of unique risk indicators currently holds more than 300,000 medical malpractice cases from 400 hospitals, including more than 30 academic and teaching hospitals covered by both captive and commercial insurers. Inclusion in this database provides an invaluable resource to organizations seeking to further contextualize their claims experience by comparison with their peers.

Our Benchmarking Reports are available, free of charge, either electronically (PDF) or in hard copy (paper) format via mail. 

benchmarking report Ambulatory Diagnosis Cover  

2014: Malpractice Risks in the Diagnostic Process

This report examines more than 4,700 diagnosis-related malpractice cases that demonstrate the pitfalls that put patients at risk of a missed or significantly delayed diagnosis. Most notably, our analysis pinpoints where in the clinician’s thought process mistakes are most likely to occur.




2013: Malpractice Risks of Routine Medical Procedures

No adverse event is “routine,” but a significant number of malpractice cases hinge on problems that occurred during the routine course of medical treatment. When a minor procedure, performed hundreds of times without incident, goes awry, we wonder “why this time?” What was different and what didn’t we anticipate or prevent that we normally do? In our fourth Comparative Benchmarking Report, we identify contributing factors and lessons learned based on analysis of 1,500 cases filed during a five-year span related to errors generated from the most common of medical procedures.




2011: Malpractice Risks in Emergency Medicine

In our analysis of 1,300 medical malpractice cases involving emergency care, we investigate Emergency Medicine’s most pressing risk: missed and delayed diagnoses. This study explores key vulnerabilities that span the entire process of care and provides innovative examples of organizations using data to address their most significant ED challenges.

We have provided some of this content on our Emergency Medicine Report Home Page.




2010: Malpractice Risks in Obstetrics

An analysis of 800 obstetrical medical malpractice cases from varied practice settings that focuses on the three
most prevalent areas of obstetrical risk:

  1. management of pregnancy,
  2. prolonged second stage labor, and
  3. operative vaginal deliveries. 

Malpractice Risks in Obstetrics also highlights examples of Strategies’ partners using CBS data to gain insight and implement solutions to enhance the safety of care delivered in their organizations.  




2009: Malpractice Risks in Surgery

This in-depth analysis of 3,000 clinically coded surgical claims and suits, from our Comparative Benchmarking System chronicles vulnerabilities throughout the perioperative process and highlights the leading factors contributing to surgical malpractice claims across specialties and care settings.